My personal view of integral life

Various Meanings of Gender Embodiment

Here is another assignment for Developmental Psychology class. This is something different. What does it mean to have “an embodied gender”? Are we naturally men or women? I’m not discussing here about masculine and feminine types though…

Embodiment as a word makes me feel that some particular feature in a human being is also in the body or manifest in the body as something measurable UR phenomena. So what we could see here when developing from the essentialist perspective the behavior of a girl would look like to be inherent in the individual as acting out in certain ways that would represent the features of a girl’s embodiment. For example “girls play with dolls” or “girls wear dresses”. Viewing especially from the essentialist point of view this kind of behavior is biologically determined. When the child grows older it seems that the constructivist view begins to “dominate” the gender development with social interactions. Gender embodiments interpreted only by the lens of essentialism seems to be of rather rational point of view (Orange as altitude). And as put in the reader: “Essentialism is the view that categories have an underlying reality or true nature that one cannot observe directly but that gives an object its identity (Gelman & Hirschfeld, 1999 etc.)”.
I see gender essentialism also as a form of biological essentialism; and from the quadrants view for example females levels of estrogen, oxytocin and testosterone as UR correlates are genetically inherited biological components that manifest in UL for example as certain feelings or sensations. In the case of oxytocin more caring and compassion and in the case of testosterone in male more towards agency and independence; possibly towards physical aggression.

So what I’m desperately trying to say here is that the gender embodiment seems to be of various types being biologically and socially shaped at different developmental stages of a boy or a girl. From the social or constructivist view this differentiation to integration and stage unfolding “process of individualization is referring to the changes in a person’s relationships to himself and to the external world” constituting his life structure (Levinson, 1978, p.195). Problems of gender embodiments through the levels lens can be experienced in various ways depending on the developmental stage the person is at. Females tend to evolve from selfish (egocentric) to care (ethnocentric) to universal care (worldcentric) to integral and therefore the gender embodiments appear in different ways at different stages. For example at ethnocentric or amber stage women tend to see their identity in a context of their relationship with the family and people around her (work etc.) and judged by responsibility and care for the closest people around her. When transcending to worldcentric stage and including the ethnocentric stage her gender embodiment changes: now she sees her in relationship with all of us, with all the people and her identity is not defined just with her relationship in the group of family but as a part of the whole world.

One of the tenets of feminist theory is that theory must be “embodied.”

Now that is an interesting and a hard statement. I am really not sure what this exactly means since the word embodiment in this context might mean totally different than for example in terms of gender.
I think that embodied theory requires interaction between theories about the body and analysis of the particularities of embodied experiences and practices; symbolic and material, body and embodiment in self, culture and nature viewed from integrally informed perspective.

About these ads

Tagged as: , ,

Categorised in: Development, Integral, Psychology

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

RSS Helsinki Paleo

  • Helsinki Paleo T-paidat September 10, 2014
    Helsinki Paleon T-paitoja on kyselty vuosia ja nyt on tulossa mahdollisuus tilata niitä! :) Paidat tekee Sieltä kerrottiin seuraavaa: Paidat ovat pehmeää 100 % luomupuuvillaa ja ne painetaan Suomessa. Miehille ja naisille on omat mallit ja kummatkin on kivasti istuvia – ei säkkejä. Paidan värinä antrasiitti ja printti valkoisella. Jos lö […]
    Jaakko Savolahti
  • Maanantain menestystarina: Vältetty refluksileikkaus September 8, 2014
      Vaiheikas yhteiselo vatsahappojen kanssa alkoi parikymppisenä opiskeluelämän myötä, mihin näin jälkiviisastellen raamitin varsin suotuisat olosuhteet. Aikataulutettu elämä eteni luentojen, jumppien ja töiden väliä sinkoillessa ja kokkailu jäi yleensä kaiken muun varjoon. Pahvilatte lounaaksi, laukun pohjalle unohtunut proteiinipatukan jämä välipalaksi ja i […]
    Jaakko Savolahti
  • Paleokeittokirja suomeksi September 4, 2014
    Thomas Rode Andersenin Paleokeittokirja – Kivikauden ruokaa modernilla otteella on ilmestynyt suomennettuna ja sain sen arvioitavaksi Atena Kustannukselta. Tästä postauksesta löydät mun arviot ja ajatukset kirjasta, kokkailutestauksen tulokset sekä alennustilauslinkin. Aluksi lukijalle reiluuden nimissä tiedoksi muutama asia: 1) Sain kirjan ilmaiseksi sillä […]
    Jaakko Savolahti

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,795 other followers

%d bloggers like this: